Strongest Fighting Fish

O

OnTheFly

Well-known member
Joined
May 3, 2009
Messages
2,906
Location
Oregon City
Just curious what other people's opinion is of what they feel is the strongest fighting fish. This is based on pound for pound. For instance; a ten pound rainbow trout against a ten pound brookie. Or a five pound bass against a five pound pike. Or a 50 pound halibut vs. a 50 pound yellow fin tuna. etc. If you don't have a single fish in mind then perhaps share some experiences through other comparasins.

Personally I feel that, pound for pound, the Bonita is the strongest.
 
Last edited:
F

fishnquest

Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2009
Messages
416
Location
9mi beyond end of the world
I got into a school of skates once; must have been 35 years ago. Not too big, but until you get them flipped over, you do NOT reel them in. Impressive fighters, imho.
 
T

Troutier Bassier

Active member
Joined
Mar 27, 2009
Messages
2,357
Location
Troutdale, Oregon
Bluegill, They are the Smallest Fish but They Fight like a Ford F-150 On a Ultralight Rod,
And Imaging if they got to 20 to 40 Inchs, People would have to use Sturgeon Rods,

Other then That, Sturgeon are Swimming Logs.
 
O

OnTheFly

Well-known member
Joined
May 3, 2009
Messages
2,906
Location
Oregon City
Bluegill, They are the Smallest Fish but They Fight like a Ford F-150 On a Ultralight Rod,
And Imaging if they got to 20 to 40 Inchs, People would have to use Sturgeon Rods,

Other then That, Sturgeon are Swimming Logs.


Remember..pound for pound. 30lb sturgeon or 30lb. halibut?
 
D

Drew9870

Banned User
Joined
Jan 23, 2009
Messages
1,066
Location
North Salem, Oregon
20lb Carp vs. 20lb Salmon

I know I know, everyone (including me) would say Salmon because you can actually eat it, but Salmon and Carp are pretty comparable when it comes to the fight.

Some guy tried telling me that Bass fight harder than Carp yesterday :lol::lol::lol:, I don't dislike bass, but ain't no bass thats gonna grab your bait and make you think your gonna get unspooled, and your more likely to catch a 20lb Carp than a 20lb Bass.
 
O

osmosis

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 20, 2008
Messages
846
Location
Trapped inside my own mind.
I agree that carp can fight very well.
lb for lb, a bluegill is a serious scrapper.
a 10lb bluegill would be extremely exciting.
 
F

FishSchooler

Active member
Joined
Mar 29, 2008
Messages
1,785
Location
Oregon
People say shad fight better than steelhead lb for lb...
 
K

Kodiak

Banned User
Joined
Jul 7, 2008
Messages
844
Location
Mill City, Oregon
small mouth are pretty tough, blue gill are scrappy too....but to truely get strong fighting fish you must hit the amazon. They have spiecies down there that make our north american fish seem very weak by compairison. But in our country LB for LB I'm gonna vote for the rock fish, they routinely exceed thousands of LBS, they are in every fishery we have, and only a handfull are landed each season, my second choice would be the log fish.
 
B

beaverfan

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 18, 2009
Messages
2,179
Location
Beaverton, Oregon
Ah the Rock Fish, King of all fish! I succesfully landed a Rockfish Smolt on the Wilson one time! But I've hooked into some doozy's. Never hooked into a log fish...yet, but I've caught dozens of there smaller cousins the stick fish and the leaf fish. As far as "living" fish are concerned lb. for lb. I gotta give it to Suckers, there little beasts.
 
O

osmosis

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 20, 2008
Messages
846
Location
Trapped inside my own mind.
The dreaded granite grouper is a plague in all of our fisheries, Those suckers grab your gear and dont budge (most of the time), very few are landed every year :D.
I do fish AK often and would LOVE to live there, but I'm from Idaho origionally. However I've lived most of my life here in Oregon. Spent a couple years down in CA too, in Diamond bar/Pomona.
 
A

adambomb

Member
Joined
Mar 22, 2009
Messages
354
Location
Forest Grove
I also would rank blue gill up there on my list, but I would have to give the number one spot to native cutthroat. I am still amazed how fast those little guys can head shake. If salmon and steelhead could head shake as fast as a ten inch cutt, we would be using steel braided cable:D
 
F

fishnquest

Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2009
Messages
416
Location
9mi beyond end of the world
The dreaded granite grouper is a plague in all of our fisheries, Those suckers grab your gear and dont budge (most of the time), very few are landed every year :D.
I do fish AK often and would LOVE to live there, but I'm from Idaho origionally. However I've lived most of my life here in Oregon. Spent a couple years down in CA too, in Diamond bar/Pomona.

ty. I did not know that; sounds like the devil is in zion.
I grew up in Napa, SF bay area. Lived 3 or 4 years as a yut in sandy eggo. My mom's side is from Pocatello.
 
O

osmosis

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 20, 2008
Messages
846
Location
Trapped inside my own mind.
steelhead and chinook smolt do the same type of thing as the cutts. I've always enjoyed how acrobatic many cutts are also, practically the instant you hook 'em they are jumping all over.

We landed a decent sized granite grouper last year, kept it too just for good luck! Still have it sitting in my tackle room..

I'm from just down the road as your Mom, Good 'ol Nampa!
 
Last edited:
F

FishFinger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 27, 2008
Messages
1,223
Location
Central Oregon
People say shad fight better than steelhead lb for lb...

As much as I hate to say it it might not even be lb for lb issue with shad. Impressive fight for a fish you can't eat w/o slow cooking if for 3 months.
 
S

SmallStreams

Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
265
Location
Oregon City
When I was a child, I think channel catfish put up the biggest fight. Hard enough fight that a 6-yr-old couldn't land a 14" fish at Devils Lake. I couldn't reel it in and walking backwards up the boat ramp area wasn't working, either.

Among the small trout, the lean & mean redsides make for the longest fights.
 

Similar threads

G
Replies
5
Views
462
hobster
hobster
Top Bottom