Pickled chinook?

So I pickled a few pounds of a chinook I caught in Dec. and it came out way mushier than the couple times I've pickled coho with the same recipe. Like, pretty much too mushy to eat normally (by itself, with crackers, etc.)

Anyone have any ideas on how to use it? Anyone had this happen before? Was trying to pickle chinook a mistake, or was it maybe just this particular chinook? BTW, it was straight out of tidewater, bright, and flesh cut fine and has been great for all the other things I made with it.
 
we do lots of smoke-then-can and both the coho and chinook turn out fantastic. as for pickling, my only thought is that chinook normally has a higher fat content, perhaps that effected the results?...
 
I just began to look into pickling herring recently so I can make something like my mother used to. She was Danish. I know that with herring, it has to be salted first and then pickled. I don't know if that would apply to salmon as well.
 
Sure worked well with coho, couldn't get enough. Easy too - just chopped up raw coho, onions, and garlic, and threw it in a big jar with apple cider vinegar and sugar (you can find some pointers online for the ratios), seemed to be best after about 10 days.

C-Run might be onto something, as some recipes called for salting the fish first and some don't, and I didn't salt. And Roger - I bet the high fat content of the chinook does factor in.

Until further evidence appears, I think I can definitely say stick to coho for pickling!
 
Top Bottom