The thing i like better about fishing indicators is you snag up less,it's easier to cast and tell if you have a bite i do know a lot of people that use 1-3 split shot and 1 egg pattern because it works for them. it's all just personal preference i think But i guess like you pointed out there are certain situations where one works better then the other. another thing that determines what you catch fish with is confidence, it is a big factor. when i first started fly fishing steel i had trouble sticking to one type of fly/technique and i was wasting my time by constantly changing the type of water i fish and what i was fishing with. And once i started hooking them with the indicator rig i threw everything else out the window :lol: