Thanks for the input. It turns out there are 3 things it could be. There are two gaskets and a diaphragm that could be the issue. I guess the gasgets are close to the same size but not exactly the same. So, I might misassembled after cleaning. Not sure if it is a big issue or not.
I will to try and find time tonight to work on it. So who said you can't learn as you go. thanks guys