If it was me I'd take all of them, repair/clean them up and see what you've got...keep the Shimanos, they're great and you have a 2000 (for trout) and a 4000 (for salmon or steelhead) if they're in good shape...if salmon/steelhead aren't your bag I'd keep the Shimano 2000 and the guide series one (brand ?) ....The rods could be a different story, just look at 'em close (guides, wrapping, reel seat, etc), choose the 2 longest rods to go with the reels you select ....you could try to sell or just donate the rest