SteelmonKiller20 said:
I catch almost every steelhead without scent...Unless i'm plunking in some dirty a** water and that's maybe two days a winter...
Present your offering correctly and you won't need scent...
-My 2 cents
Yes and no.
Sometimes, when I've beaten bigger runs to death when I was confident there was fish there (I'm generally a stick-and-move guy, but we all stay at that one hole when we've got that fishy feeling, right?), after forgetting or foregoing scent, I've added it, then hooked up shortly thereafter. I've been doing my deal, similar techniques, right or wrong, for a long time now, and it's happened enough that I can no longer chalk it up as coincidence. I smoke (often like a chimney on a cold day), so maybe that offsets it, but since fish react to scent, I doubt it can hurt.
Most of the successful steelie fishermen I know (most more successful than I, a couple who guise) are pretty firm believers in scent, although I'll agree presentation is by far the most important thing.
I'm also a firm believer in going with what works for you, and if you catch, you'd be a fool to change anything based upon anything I, or anyone else here says.