Sickles: good vs/ bad

F

fish_4_all

Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2008
Messages
412
Location
Aberdeen, WA
I just some more sickle octopus hooks and I finaly see what a bad sickle looks like.
badsickles.jpg
As you can see, the hook on the right has much more severe bends instead of the gradual bends of the one on the left. The first bend broke under light pressure in a fly tying vise where the otherswould deform and bend out instead of breaking. If you look really close the first bend is a kink instead of a bend and it is obvious why these hooks would fail fighting a fish.

The hooks are a 1/0 Matzuo Octopus hook.

I thought I would share this so those of you that use them will have a reference to see if you have gotten good quality sickle hooks or a bad brittle run.

Todd, thank you for making me aware of the differences so I knew what to look for. Would have sucked to lose a couple summers on these from a hook breaking.
 
D

Diehard

Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2008
Messages
153
Location
damascus
i recently bought some of these brand in a 2/0 jig hook. and recently caught an 11.5 lb sthlhead on one of these. i was also useing 8lb leader and by the time i got this fish netted it had almost got the hook straightened out i think the wire is just to thin or bad temper on these hooks because an 8lb leader should not be straightenig them out imo. i was going to bump down to a 1/0 but maybe ill just go back to my bullet proof owner hooks
 
F

fish_4_all

Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2008
Messages
412
Location
Aberdeen, WA
For sickle jig hooks you want the 3x wire ones. The light wire ones will never see my line for steelhead and salmon. I wish it was easier to get the heavy wire ones but I am still waiting to get them.
 
E

eat, sleep, fish

Active member
Joined
Sep 1, 2010
Messages
318
Location
On the Rogue
After using them for a little bit springer fishing last year I'll never use them again. They straightened out on me way to easily and cost me a few fish. It may have been a bad batch, but I've never had a Gami fail me.
 
F

fish_4_all

Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2008
Messages
412
Location
Aberdeen, WA
Never had that problem but then again I have bent tips and bent out Gamis before so maybe it is just part of the match the tackle to your fishing techniques. My sickles buried so deep straightening them wasn't ever an issue. But i fisha ll barbless so maybe that made a difference also. Grinding the barb off left a long point to go to the bend on any hook set. These were octopus hooks not jig hooks. Like i said, I will not use the regular witre ones for slamon nor steelhead. Way too light a wire and very likely to bend out under a good fight or pulling as hard as we need to sometimes on a nice fish with an attitude.

I did get ahold of captain hooks and they are going to replace the hooks for me. Replied in one day and were more than happy to do so. Even going to inspect the hooks this time.

For jig hooks I just got a big order from Pbug of Mustad 32833 and I doubt even a 50#+ Chinook could straighten them out.
 
Last edited:
Gunga

Gunga

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Messages
300
Which one of the hooks that you posted is the bad hook. i can't seem to spot the differnce.
 
G

GungasUncle

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 14, 2011
Messages
928
Location
Forest Grove, Oregon
The one on the left is the good hook, the one on the right is the bad hook. If you look close, the one on the right has more pronounced bends, sharper angles. The one on the left has more fluid, rounded bends - and is less likely to break than the one on the right.
 
P

ProfessorChromology

Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2010
Messages
38
Location
Eugene, OR
That is good information. Thanks for posting!
 
Gunga

Gunga

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Messages
300
The one on the left is the good hook, the one on the right is the bad hook. If you look close, the one on the right has more pronounced bends, sharper angles. The one on the left has more fluid, rounded bends - and is less likely to break than the one on the right.

Thanks uncle mark glad that you could help.:)
 
Top Bottom