roster tails or panther martin

D
dirtyd fishin
:think:you decide if what your favorite one is and put the post up and see wat ppl would rather use:think:
 
J
jd15
i like both but panther martins are an overall better spinner
 
Last edited:
troutdude
troutdude
I vote for Rooster Tails.
 
H
halibuthitman
always been a spoon or Mepps guy myself... but roostertails have caught me a lot of fish.. so have panthers, depends on where I am I guess.
 
brandon4455
brandon4455
roostertails. panthers are not bad but roostertails have way better size choices and color selections and have always got way more fish for me but i have caught my fair share on panthers. and roostertails dont cost a butt load for one spinner.
 
D
dirtyd fishin
i agree with u brandon its too much for one panther martin hahaha
 
J
jd15
dirtyd fishin said:
i agree with u brandon its too much for one panther martin hahaha

panther martins are worth their money tho
 
brandon4455
brandon4455
thats true. i guess this is just a personal perference matter. i PREFER roostertails because thats what i grew up fishing and roostertails have colors pm dosen't but then again, roostertails dont have pm colors. they both have their ups and downs in different conditions. i usually just fish my homeade ones or roostertails thats about it.
 
S
skunk
I am possibly the worlds worst spinner fisherman so how's this, panther martin, cause I like the name better!!! Basically I weep like a baby when I loose a lure that's over 3$, multiple times in a day. That's almost equal to a tank of gas a cast!!! Haha.
 
8
89xj
I carry both in my arsenal, I really prefer rooster tails in faster water, the thinner blade really helps to keep the lure low, when I'm fishing calm, or very slow water the presentation of a panther seems to produce more fish
 
  • Like
Reactions: brandon4455
N
nwkiller
i really like both
 

Similar threads

TheKnigit
Replies
4
Views
567
TheKnigit
TheKnigit
S
Replies
14
Views
3K
DonF
D
Trout Slayer_7
Replies
7
Views
987
Trout Slayer_7
Trout Slayer_7
FairweatherFisher
Replies
15
Views
960
Casting Call
Casting Call
D
Replies
3
Views
362
DonF
D
Top Bottom